Compare Breville and Hamilton Beach Juicers
The simplicity of the Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juice Extractor ensures an intuitive and easy juicing experience. Stability can be a bit of a problem when the machine is first turned on, but the size of the juicer makes it easy to secure while still feeding produce into the chute. There is also only one processing speed, but we didn’t find this to be a problem, even when juicing kale. In addition to the main body, there are just four components and all four of these removable parts are dishwasher safe. Combined with the brush for use on the mesh strainer, there are no cleaning challenges; this is a juicer designer for daily use. The package does not include a juice collector, nor does it include additional components aside from a cleaning brush.
Both machines made some mess on the counters, back splash, and under the cabinets when fruits and vegetables were added to the juicers. Tiny pieces of pulp would spray out from the opening while the machines were running. However, for a fraction of the price, you can attain comparable results, making the Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juice Extractor our best budget juicer pick. Did you know that 95% of the vitamins and enzymes our bodies need are found in the juice of raw fruits and vegetables? We would need to eat 2 lbs of carrots, apples, or 8 lbs of spinach to get the same amount of nutrients you receive in one 16 oz juice. For the last 3 years I have been drinking juicing recipes to keep up my vegetable intake but I also love the fresh taste!
Our third drink for testing combined beetroot, apples, carrots, sweet potatoes, and oranges. The mixture produced by this juicer was delicious but had a slightly overpowering beet flavor. There was a decent amount of pulp, and the texture was somewhat watery, but the quality was still above average.
It also benefits from one of the most simple designs, for fast assembly and cleaning. The Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juice Extractor repeatedly yields higher volumes of juice than machines which cost more than twice the price. It does this while offering a modern, inoffensive aesthetic and a compact size for easy storage. Yes, it is loud and also not the most stable, but these are minor, short-lived inconveniences; the fast cleaning and impressive yields will be far more noticeable to customers. The Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juice Extractor was the loudest of any juicer we tested, hitting a high of 91.3 dB. It was also one of the least stable models, due to its lightweight and compact size.
You may remember my first Hamilton Beach Juicer review on Stagetecture in 2012 and I’m excited to pair up with them again to feature their larger model juicer. It has much more power and I’m going to share with you how I keep juice longer in your refrigerator so you don’t have to juice as often. This metric focused on the actual yield when juicing various types of softer food and the quality of the juice generated. I thought the two machines were similar in performance, which surprised me since there was a significant price difference.
This juicer also struggled with spinach, again having a lower than average yield, but this time producing about an inch of foam. The Big Mouth started this metric with a somewhat lackluster performance at juicing carrots, generating a less than average amount of juice with mild amounts of pulp. It did much better at juicing beets, actually earning one of the highest scores of the group. We received well above the average amount of juice with only mild amounts of pulp, though it created a decent amount of foam.
Cost, size, clean-up, handling of the machine, and the fact that they were so similar in performance, were factors that led us to choose Hamilton Beach over Breville. The extra $100 for the Breville machine versus Hamilton Beach was not worth it in our opinion. I don’t see how it could be worth it for anyone, unless looks is the most important part.
The power switch is highlighted in silver for clear visibility and positioned on the front of the juicer for easy access. As mentioned earlier, it has a lightweight design, weighing just 9.56 hamilton beach toaster oven lbs. The Big Mouth did much better in our second test, a recipe of romaine lettuce, apples, and oranges. The final drink was mildly pulpy, but overall, it had a great texture and tasted fine.
Overall, it’s not the best but usually retails for substantially less than the highest-scoring models. This juicer is a fantastic value, holding its own with models that cost hundreds of dollars more. This juicer did amazingly well at juicing wheatgrass, earning one of the highest scores of the group and only outperformed by the best products in the lineup. The Big Mouth generated about 4.3mL of juice, well above the 2.5mL average. We evaluated how well each juicer did at juicing sweet potatoes, carrots, and beets for this metric. We used an identical set of criteria as the previous metric to score performance, and the Big Mouth again delivered an average performance.
We looked at each component, noting any problems we found in cleaning them, whether or not they are dishwasher-safe, and include a cleaning brush. Unfortunately, hamilton beach toaster performance dropped considerably when we tried juicing kale in the Big Mouth. Its yield was less than average, but only a minuscule amount of foam was produced.